Blog

High Water Bill Vaughan: 10 Causes and How to Fix It

A sudden spike in your water bill is one of the most common calls we receive at Hive 5 Plumbing & Drains. The good news is that many causes can be identified with simple checks before calling a plumber.

We are always happy to help - but we also believe homeowners should understand their own systems. Here is how to start investigating safely.

Published
June 22, 2026

By a Licensed Master Plumber | Hive 5 Plumbing & Drains | Serving Vaughan, Woodbridge & the York Region

Quick Answer

What causes a high water bill?

Running toilets are the most common cause, followed by dripping faucets, leaking appliances, and outdoor hose bibs left open.

Step 1: Check Your Water Meter

Your water meter is the best diagnostic tool in your home. It is usually located in the basement mechanical or furnace room. Most meters have a small dial or digital indicator that moves when water is flowing.

How to test for hidden water usage:

  1. Stop using all water in the home
  2. Make sure no toilets, faucets, or appliances are running
  3. Watch the meter dial for 10 to 15 minutes

If the dial continues moving, water is being used somewhere - even if you do not see a leak. That means something is running silently.

Why the City Sometimes Alerts You

The City of Vaughan often monitors abnormal usage and may notify homeowners when consumption spikes. That is because water conservation benefits everyone.

The drinking water we use is treated Lake Ontario water, and wastewater is processed before being returned to the same ecosystem. Protecting that cycle matters - which is one reason harsh drain chemicals like Drano are strongly discouraged.

Water is precious.

The 10 Most Common Causes of a High Water Bill

1. Running Toilets

Toilets are responsible for a huge percentage of hidden water loss. If you hear a toilet running, that is the obvious sign. But many leaks are silent.

A failed fill valve can constantly send water into the overflow tube. You will not see water on the floor - but the meter will spin and the bill will rise.

The Food Dye Test:

  1. Add a few drops of food colouring into the toilet tank
  2. Do not flush
  3. Wait 10 to 15 minutes

If colour appears in the bowl, the flush valve or flapper is leaking and needs replacement. Repeat this test for every toilet in the home.

If you need a toilet repaired or replaced, Hive 5 offers same-day service across Vaughan and Woodbridge.

2. Dripping Faucets

If your shower faucet, tub faucet, or sink faucet has a visible drip, do not ignore it. Even a slow drip wastes thousands of litres per month and adds up fast over a 60-day Vaughan billing cycle.

3. Laundry Faucets with Primer Lines

Older laundry faucets sometimes include a primer line that sends water to the floor drain to keep the trap sealed. If the faucet develops an internal leak, the water can flow directly into the drain without being visible. You may not see a leak - but water is constantly running.

If your laundry faucet is 15 to 20 years old and has a primer line, it is worth inspecting or replacing.

4. Reverse Osmosis Systems

Reverse osmosis filtration systems can occasionally get stuck in a constant drain cycle. If all other checks fail, isolate the RO system and watch the water meter again. If the meter stops moving, the system needs service.

5. Water Softeners

We have seen water softeners get stuck in regeneration or purge mode and run water 24 hours a day.

If you have a softener:

6. Outdoor Hose Bibs and Irrigation Systems

Outdoor leaks are easy to miss because the water disappears into soil and homeowners often do not notice until the bill arrives. Check for:

Summer irrigation failures are one of the most common causes of high seasonal water bills in Vaughan, Woodbridge, and Kleinburg.

7. Furnace Humidifiers

Whole-home humidifiers run water while the furnace operates. If the solenoid valve fails open, water can run continuously. This is a hidden but serious source of water loss that many Maple and Vaughan homeowners overlook heading into winter.

8. Aging Shut-Off Valves and Supply Lines

If a shut-off valve or braided supply line is slowly weeping water, it may be dripping into a cabinet or floor without being noticed. This is one of the most common findings during a Hive 5 whole home plumbing inspection.

9. Leaking Appliances

Dishwashers, refrigerators with water lines, and boiler fill valves can all leak internally without obvious signs. If you have ruled out toilets, faucets, and outdoor sources, check behind and under your major appliances.

10. Underslab Pipe Leaks

In rare cases, older copper or buried water lines can develop pinhole leaks beneath the concrete slab of a home. When this happens, water can continuously escape underground without any visible signs inside the house.

Because the leak is below the slab, homeowners may not see water damage. The only clues are often a spinning water meter, unexplained high water bills, or warm spots on the floor in heated homes.

We have encountered situations in Vaughan where these hidden underslab leaks ran for months before being discovered. While uncommon, they are important to consider when all visible plumbing checks come back normal.

Licensed & Insured
Your home and property will be protected as if it was our own hive.
24/7 Emergency
Got a last minute issue? Don't worry, our colony has you covered!
100% Satisfaction
We’ll do the job right every time, to make sure you’re bee-yond satisfied.
Free Estimates
We’ll listen to your issue and provide you with a free, no pressure quote.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much water can a leaking toilet waste?
arrow_forward_ios

A silent toilet leak can waste hundreds of litres per day - sometimes thousands over a month. Because the leak is invisible and constant, many homeowners do not realize it is happening until the bill arrives. We have seen real cases where running toilets led to $400 to $1,200 water bills in a single billing cycle. In Vaughan, billing cycles are typically around 60 days, which means by the time you receive the notice, the leak may have already been running for months.

What is the most common cause of a high water bill?
arrow_forward_ios

Running toilets are the number one cause. Silent toilet leaks account for a huge percentage of abnormal household water usage.

When should I call a plumber?
arrow_forward_ios

If the water meter keeps spinning and you cannot isolate the cause, it is time to call. Professional plumbers have leak detection tools and experience that prevent unnecessary wall or floor damage during investigation.

Can appliances cause a hidden water leak?
arrow_forward_ios

Yes. Reverse osmosis systems, dishwashers, refrigerators with water lines, softeners, humidifiers, and boiler fill valves can all leak internally without obvious signs. Appliances are a frequent source of silent water loss.

Can a humidifier really use that much water?
arrow_forward_ios

Yes. Whole-home humidifiers intentionally use water during furnace operation, but if the solenoid valve fails open, they can run continuously. Because the water drains automatically, homeowners rarely notice until the bill spikes.

Can irrigation systems cause a hidden leak?
arrow_forward_ios

Absolutely. Underground sprinkler leaks, stuck valves, or broken lines can dump water into soil with no visible puddle. Summer irrigation failures are a common cause of high seasonal bills in Vaughan and across York Region.

Do water softeners waste a lot of water?
arrow_forward_ios

Modern softeners are efficient, but a malfunctioning unit can get stuck in regeneration mode and run water constantly. If your softener sounds like it is always cycling, it should be inspected.

Can a high water bill ever be a billing mistake?
arrow_forward_ios

Yes. Whole-home humidifiers intentionally use water during furnace operation, but if the solenoid valve fails open, they can run continuously. Because the water drains automatically, homeowners rarely notice until the bill spikes.

Can I request a lower bill from the city after a leak is fixed?
arrow_forward_ios

Sometimes, yes. In our experience, the City of Vaughan may review unusually high bills if homeowners can provide proof that a hidden leak existed and was professionally repaired. This usually involves submitting invoices, repair documentation, or inspection reports. Approval is not guaranteed and policies can vary, but it is always worth contacting the city and asking about a leak adjustment review. Many municipalities understand that hidden plumbing leaks can happen and may offer partial relief when proper repairs are documented.

If the Meter Is Still Spinning After All Your Checks

If you have worked through every item above and the meter is still moving, it is time to call a professional. Hive 5 Plumbing & Drains specializes in water loss diagnosis and hidden leak detection across Vaughan, Woodbridge, and York Region.

Professional plumbers have leak detection tools and experience that prevent unnecessary wall or floor damage during investigation. Water waste adds up quickly. The sooner it is addressed, the better.

Call or text (647) 535-5560 for same-day leak detection in Vaughan and surrounding areas.